Fellow Lemmy users,
The Lemmy development team is considering adding a new tag system that would allow us to tag posts with keywords. This could make it easier to search for and find content on Lemmy.
Before implementing this, the team would like our feedback as users. Specifically:
-
Do you think having post tags would be helpful on Lemmy? Why or why not?
-
How should tags be displayed and integrated into Lemmy?
Please share your thoughts on whether you’d find a tag system useful, and if so, how you’d want it implemented. The dev team reads the feedback and will use it to decide how to proceed.
To give your input, you can comment or vote here or on the GitHub issue[1]. You can vote whether or not you want the feature, and the different implementations, so we can see which is the most popular.
Thanks for helping shape Lemmy! This is our community, so please speak up.
Looking forward to hearing your thoughts.
You must log in or # to comment.
Yes, please.
Also group-agnostic filtering would be useful. Lemmy groups are sparsely filled and it would make more sense to “subscribe to a tag” than a group.
Yes! I speak to give this comment more weight and I’m not holding my peace!
Same. I’ve really liked this feature in Mastadon.
A flair-like implementation would be nice for certain communities. From past experience on reddit, I can see how it could be beneficial to filter a community’s posts through tags, say, to check latest announcements or new support questions. I’d personally prefer community-specific tags as opposed to global post tags
(which is what I inferred from this post’s content, I haven’t read the RFC yet though)edit: the RFC talks about both instance-based tags and community-based tags, which is even betterOne of the use cases on Reddit is to tag titles that are misleading/wrong/changed, which doesn’t matter as much here where titles can be edited.
I definitely agree about community specific tags. Filtering by, for example, community announcements, news, or discussion posts can be pretty helpful on bigger communities. We could self-enforce that for searchability with [terms in brackets], but a drop-down to select tags would be a lot smoother.
A string like name@example.com can mean different things in lemmy.
If prepended with an exclamation it’s a community, and with an “at” is a user.
https://join-lemmy.org/docs/administration/federation_getting_started.htmlWhat would be the symbol for the tags? A hash?
My only thoughts are about abuse, have the devs thought about how to limit abuse of a tagging system?
My suggestions were limit number to 5 user applicable tags, communities having a whitelist of tags, and an instance’s slur filter applying to tags.
Tumblr tags come to mind
Yes. Good idea.
I don’t know a thing about developing a platform but tags sound great. Like the other commenter said, similar to Reddit flairs could work. I think both categories of tags, community and instance, would be useful.
I would like to have user-based tags, in addition to community, instance, and post-level. It’s nice to be able to rag the trolls or bad-faith actors.
I think that would make a lot of sense considering the different communities about similar topic on different instances, can’t replace a proper search engine but I get that that would be really expensive to host (you would have to basically index Lemmy) and that’s a nice option for official discoverability support. The biggest issue in that regard will continue be the architecture of current search engines tho, Fediverse applications can’t rank properly in a domain based system and a Reddit alternative MUST rank in search engines to be viable!
