Questions:

  • Can you test 450V high ripple current caps with a any old desktop RCL meter?
  • Has digikey shipped me faulty units?

Background:

I’ve gotten a couple of 660uF (not a typo, it’s some weird high ripple current caps for an outdoor AC unit) 450V caps to replace some that I decided were duds. Normally I only measure components when troubleshooting, but this being 20USD with vat devices I thought “what the heck, I better”.

The caps in question are chemi-con EKHJ451VSN661MA59M https://www.digikey.dk/en/products/detail/chemi-con/EKHJ451VSN661MA59M/17728502.

Method:

I’m using a Phillips PM6303A, which is a 1kHz RCL meter. Ambiant temp is approx 15°C. The caps have a 20% tolerance, so capacity should be >528uF, but when measuring both caps settle at approx 450uF after a little while. After 16hours it hasn’t deviated for the one cap I’ve left in over night. The dissipation factor, tan(δ), settled at 0.57, while the datasheet states that it shall be no greater than 0.2.

For comparison, the caps I thought was faulty, have been running for about 20years, with the same specs, but came out to 550uF and 0.3, and as the spec said 0.2 I decided to change them.

    • BigDanishGuy@sh.itjust.worksOPEnglish
      3·
      1 year ago

      Well I guess, I’ve got a sweeping function gen and a 4ch DSO… I’m gonna look into that and get back.

      Caveat: my engineering diploma in embedded electronics is 10 years old, and it’s been awhile since I’ve done more than just the odd solder job. So it’s going to take a little while.

      • BigDanishGuy@sh.itjust.worksOPEnglish
        1·
        1 year ago

        @gondezee@lemmy.world when you say “plot a frequency sweep” what you’re looking for is just the usual voltage/time graph from a scope? No resistance in parallel to the capacitor for discharge? No fixed resistance in series? No x/y graphing funny business?

        Or are you looking for a bode plot? I was hesitant in my first response because I thought I remembered Dave doing a bode plot with a sweeping gen and a scope, but I wasn’t sure if I could find it. I could https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=uMH2hGvqhlE

    • BigDanishGuy@sh.itjust.worksOPEnglish
      1·
      1 year ago

      I think I’ve managed to do what you asked, let me know if I messed it up.

      I got my function gen to do 6.1-12 in two decades x100 and x1000. The sweeps are almost linear after the first 500ms, meaning that each horizontal division of each 200ms denotes the following:

      Timemark Frequency
      0 6.1kHz
      200ms 6.1kHz
      400ms 6.1kHz
      600ms 10.2kHz
      800ms 22.7kHz
      1000ms 36.2kHz
      1200ms 50kHz
      1400ms 64.1kHz
      1600ms 78.1kHz
      1800ms 92.6k
      2000ms 106kHz
      2200ms 119kHz

      With all that said here’s the data

      Replacement cap 610-12k

      Original cap 610-12k

      Replacement cap 6.1k-120k

      Original cap 6.1k-120k