Quote from the Archwiki (Installation guide):

Arch Linux should run on any x86_64-compatible machine with a minimum of 512 MiB RAM, though more memory is needed to boot the live system for installation. A basic installation should take less than 2 GiB of disk space.

Does that mean it is technically possible to get a Windows XP-era device with 512 Mb RAM and install Arch on it by pulling out the hard drive, connecting it to a modern machine via a SATA to usb connector, for example, with the modern machine running the live environment, and then just partitioning and installing on the old computer HDD, then putting the hdd back on the old computer? Is something like that feasible? I don’t have a machine to test it on, but it certainly sounds like a fun experiment. It sort of reminds me of the stories of Gentoo cross-compiling.

Edit: It is a HYPOTHETICAL question. Please focus on the METHOD and IMPLEMENTATION instead of 32-bit compatibility or driver issues.

  • traches@sh.itjust.worksEnglish
    2·
    1 year ago

    Wouldn’t most of those old computers be 32 bit? I remember trying to throw arch on an old winxp netbook and running into that issue.

  • LiveLM@lemmy.zipEnglish
    1·
    1 year ago

    I think so, yeah.
    Though Alpine would be probably easier to get going given the super tiny size.

  • casualdan@beehaw.org
    1·
    1 year ago

    The requirement for x86_64 eliminates most XP era machines, though I was certainly running XP well into the Vista era on potentially compatible hardware.

    How old are you thinking?

  • insomniac@sh.itjust.works
    1·
    1 year ago

    I have a Thinkpad T400 with Arch on it. It came out in 2008 which I believe is the last year XP got a release. But I’m pretty sure it came with Vista.

    It runs like shit with a full desktop environment but with i3, it’s decent. I haven’t used it in a little while because I upgraded to a luxurious T440 recently but I have Intellij and Docker running on it. I can do most of my programming things. It’s definitely good enough for browsing the internet or running Libre Office.

  • somenonewho@feddit.de
    1·
    1 year ago

    So. To answer you “hypothetical” question if we ignore all the factors making it complicated (like 32bit compatibility, drivers, etc.)

    Yes it is “feasible” to Install an OS using a modern System and just pull out the HDD and shove it into an old system. Especially since the way BIOS/MBR (aka “Legacy Boot”) is the exact same on all systems you write the “what to start” code in the first few Bytes on the HDD (aka the MBR) and set a bootable flag on the device. Now you can pull it out and plug it into any other machine which will simply “look” for a bootable flag and then run the code in the MBR (usually a bootloader). This bootloader (usually grub for legacy systems) will then execute one of its boot entries and start a kernel. This is probably where a real world example fails because of the problems mentioned by everyone here.

  • Cwilliams@beehaw.org
    0·
    11 months ago

    “I have this really hard problem. If you disregard all of the hard parts, what are the hard parts?”