They have warned about this before, but it’s still pretty wild to think they’re now removing old DMs (and chats, but it’s not like anyone used those).
Interestingly you can still see them if you take out your data via a request, so they got them in the database still.
adults in the 2000’s: “just remember, anything you put online is gonna be there forever.”
It’s true, but it only applies to the stuff you don’t want there anymore.
Stuff you’re actively trying to preserve is made of glass and disappears if you don’t look at it for more than a week.
Looking at you YouTube, deleting videos and removing any trace of them from my playlists. Sad that you got to download so much these days or it’s just gone because a pixel or a single audio nanosecond will get it flagged and deleted.
Indeed. It’s still a good rule of thumb to remember and teach to kids getting used to the internet. Post something on social media that you might regret later, and there’s absolutely a chance that it gets downloaded, reuploaded, and circulated without your consent. Which at that point, it’s too late to control.
It’s useful lesson: think twice before uploading something to make sure you won’t regret it later.
Wise man
Unsaid part of that adage was “…in the public”.
People forget about nefarious corporations keeping privately shared stuff indefinitely even if you explicitly tell them not to. Or if they swear it’s getting deleted.
Also, another part of the adage that is incorrect is a corollary to Murphy’s Law. “If you put something online publicly and you expect it to stay online forever, it’s not going to, usually due to corporate bullshit.”
Well it seems it is still there, just no longer shown in the UI. So I dunno. 🤷
Nah this is the general advice for posting/doing something you will regret 5 years down the road.
Late to the party there, they did that last week
Wonder how the GDPR is playing a role here. There’s supposed to be a data retention clause that you can only keep actively used data / essential information. It could be them reacting to provisions like that or they could just be making more terrible adhoc changes…
GDPR is not at play here, private messages are essential data if one of the purposes of your app is messaging. But now they’ll have to delete them because they’re no longer necessary since the user can’t see them. Though it doesn’t have to be immediate.
So much OF spam and conservative harassment, gone!
Are they removing old bans?
I don’t like the other stuff they’re doing but I don’t think this is that unreasonable. They’re not a messaging platform. They’re a heavily organized forum that allows messaging. Deprecating an old messages/chat format and not thinking it’s worth it to try to retroactively migrate over a decade of content when most users won’t care at all isn’t that unreasonable. There’s a scale where, especially with legacy code in play, migrating old data is a serious undertaking that takes serious resources. If it’s not something critical that most people use, you have to evaluate whether it’s worth it.
All of that is true, but they also could’ve said “Hey, we’re deleting these messages in a week, back up anything important, sorry for the short notice” and that would have been A-OK. Some people lost some sentimental messages and weren’t prepared to back them up because there was zero warning that this was happening.
Someone said they’re still part of the GDPR export, you can try that. If it doesn’t work, use a VPN to connect from an EU country.
Are you sure they didn’t give warning? I completely stopped visiting the site when they announced they were taking my app away, but I could have sworn I’ve seen mentions that they were building new chat/messages and that old ones would be gone for a while now. Well before any of the current API stuff.
I still have all my messages, including the original ‘Welcome to Reddit’ message from 7 years ago:
